What Can Be Recycled?

Below is a list of plastic packaging in our stores that can be recycled through the new #5 plastics collection program.

Yes

Dairy Department

  • Cottage cheese containers
  • Butterworks Yogurt (#2 plastic)
  • Sour cream containers
  • Cream cheese containers
  • Dip containers
  • Pudding containers
  • Spreads containers
  • Mediterranean Delight Hummus
  • Bobbi’s Hummus
  • Margarine tubs
  • Yogurt tubs (see exceptions, below)
  • Lids from Brown Cow, Cabot and Stonyfield products are #5. Other lids may be recyclable as well. Look for the 5 symbol.
  • Kraft Deli Fresh Slices boxes
  • Cabot Cheddar Shake

Grocery

  • Frosting tubs
  • Baby wipe containers
  • Red caps from Sun Maid raisin containers
  • Brita Filters

Bulk Department

  • Round containers (base only)

Cheese Department

  • VT Butter and Cheese Company
  • Some specialty cheese containers—ricotta, parmesan, romano

Produce Department

  • Maya Kaimal containers
  • VegetaBalls pesto containers
  • VT Fresh pasta sauces containers
  • Marzetti fruit dips containers
  • Bear Pond Pestos

Health and Beauty Department

  • Preserve Toothbrushes
  • Deoderant casing
  • Some skin crème containers

Brita Filters
Brita filters are now recyclable at the Co-op! Want to know more?

No

Dairy Department

  • Nancy’s Yogurt (#2 plastic)
  • Erivan Yogurt, 16 ounce (#2 plastic)
  • Multi-pack yogurts, all brands (#6 plastic)
  • Hannah spreads containers with twist tops (#3 plastic)
Consumer News - Current Issue